Medela vs. Spectra: comparing two leading breast pump brands

When it comes to choosing the best breast pump, you may be wondering how two of the most reputable brands in the market stack up against each other. Medela and Spectra both offer high-quality, efficient pumps that have helped millions of mothers worldwide.

Background on Medela and Spectra


Medela has been at the forefront of breastfeeding support for over 60 years. Known for its innovative research in lactation technology, Medela’s breast pumps are developed based on clinical evidence to support mothers throughout their breastfeeding journey, making it a trusted choice among healthcare professionals and mothers alike.


A newer player, Spectra has gained a reputation for high-performance, feature-rich breast pumps that offer exceptional comfort. Spectra’s products are designed by registered nurses and lactation consultants, focusing on creating pumps that are not only effective but also extremely gentle. The brand is acclaimed for its quiet, user-friendly, and innovative designs, making Spectra a popular choice among tech-savvy parents.

Comparing Medela and Spectra

Design and ease of use

Medela pumps, including the popular Pump In Style, are known for their durability and robust motor that mimics the natural suckling of a baby. They tend to be straightforward with easy-to-use controls, making them a great choice for mothers who appreciate simplicity and efficiency.

Spectra, on the other hand, offers a more modern look with their pumps like the Spectra S1 and S2. These pumps feature a digital display with customizable settings that allow mothers to control the speed and rhythm of the pump. Spectra’s pumps are also lighter and quieter compared to many models offered by Medela, which is a significant advantage for mothers who may need to pump near a sleeping baby or in a public setting.

Performance and comfort

Medela’s 2-Phase Expression technology is highly effective, especially in models like the Pump In Style. This technology allows for faster let-down and maximizes milk output, which is ideal for mothers who are often pressed for time.

Spectra pumps, including the S1, S2, and the portable Spectra 9, feature a gentle pumping experience that many mothers find more comfortable. The adjustable suction levels and a massage mode that simulates a baby’s natural nursing pattern contribute to a more natural and comfortable pumping experience.

Portability and power options

Medela’s Pump In Style is designed for mothers on the go, offering a portable solution with a battery pack option. However, it is generally heavier than Spectra’s portable options like the Spectra 9, which is designed for travel and weighs significantly less.

Spectra S1 and S2 come with built-in rechargeable batteries, making them highly portable without the need for external batteries. The Spectra 9 is particularly compact and ideal for travel, fitting easily into a diaper bag or purse.

Hygiene and maintenance

Both brands prioritize hygiene with closed system pumps, preventing milk from entering the tubes or the motor. This system ensures that the milk stays pure and the components are easier to clean and maintain.

Product Highlights

Medela Pump In Style

Ideal for daily use, with a powerful motor and built-in battery pack for pumping anywhere.

Spectra S1 and S2

Known for their quiet operation and customizable settings, with a rechargeable battery in S1 for cordless use.

Spectra 9

Ultra-portable and lightweight, perfect for mothers who need to pump on the move.

Which pump will be your favorite?

Both Medela and Spectra offer exceptional breast pumps that cater to different needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize portability, comfort, or simplicity, both brands provide reliable solutions that support your breastfeeding goals. When choosing between Medela and Spectra, consider how often you’ll be using the pump, where you’ll be using it, and what features are most important to you. By understanding the strengths of each brand and model, you can make an informed decision that best suits your lifestyle and breastfeeding needs.

Need more help deciding?

Choosing the right breast pump is a personal decision and might require a bit more guidance. Don’t hesitate to get in touch with us at Milk N Mamas Baby. Our team of experts is here to provide personalized guidance to help you find the perfect pump that meets your needs. Contact us today to make your breastfeeding journey as smooth and successful as possible!